Responding to Reviewer 2
PN
Dr. Priya Nair
Senior Editor, Engineering · Aug 7, 2026 · 7 min read
Drop the article's cover image
Every author eventually meets the reviewer whose comments feel personal, vague, or simply wrong.
Our response-letter framework separates a comment's valid technical core from its tone, then answers only the former, point by point.
"You are not obligated to agree with a reviewer — only to answer them completely."
This is the same structure our editors use drafting response letters for Advanced and Platinum clients.